/ Platforms

The Top Class Wednesday Update is slightly cheapened, or is it?

Hello, me again. Thanks Rich for an excellent Update last week. I must say Iโ€™m not a fan of 2026 so far. It has had a couple of good bits, but far more demerits and should now be considering its position before getting placed on a Performance Improvement Plan.  

Iโ€™m #delighted this is the last Update of January, and even more #delighted that Iโ€™ve got some Actual News to write about which isnโ€™t to do with the imminent destruction of civilisation as we know it.  

And so our eyes turn West to the Beast from Bristol, who has announced a 0.1% cut in its main custody fees, balanced with a bunch of other changes including introducing fund trading fees. This is quite bold, and we should pay attention. 

The reason we should pay attention is that HL is of course a behemoth and a bellwether for the sector. That isnโ€™t to say itโ€™s a pricing anchor for others; most everyone has been way cheaper for ages, but in the main they donโ€™t have two million clients and the thick end of ยฃ200bn and HL does.  

I remember doing investor presentations a decade or so ago, and being asked by various Kenneths and Henrys how long it was reasonable to assume HL would defend its famously toppy 0.45% charge for. Not being Punxsutawney Phil (who by the way will be doing his schtick this weekend) I would generally say I didnโ€™t know the answer, but as long as they were growing and continuing to punch their considerable weight, they wouldnโ€™t be rushing to change for the sake of it.  

Anyway, hereโ€™s a thing: HL is still growing handily. Itโ€™s still punching its weight in all kinds of areas and is still the one everyone wants to beat. Itโ€™s also now a private company after delisting in March last year, so the nip-nip-nip scrutiny of being a listed business is reduced, and that will be a relief. So why has it cut its own throat now? Especially when it has some big tech spend coming up, and when itโ€™s clear thereโ€™s lots of other strategic change to deal with?  

Most folk will say itโ€™s because of competitive pressures; neo-platforms coming on at low low low prices and the other big shops like ii and AJ Bell YouInvest eating its lunch. Iโ€™m sure that contributes, but Iโ€™m not sure itโ€™s what it first appears. I donโ€™t think itโ€™s cut its own throat at all. 

Letโ€™s do some arithmetic. The average holding on HL per client is around ยฃ90,000 (not that averages are much help, but hear me out). Weโ€™ll bump that up to ยฃ100k for fun. So letโ€™s take a ยฃ100k ISA portfolio, which trades in funds 10 times a year. Here are a few key runners and riders:

Letโ€™s not get too excited โ€“ that new trading charge really does pull back the discount a bit. So a question: if you were on a defensive price play strategy to stem outflows, would you choose to be ยฃ190 a year more than a key competitor like ii for this fictional client? Iโ€™m not sure I would. 

HL has a very broad proposition now, and I think that might be the key to some of whatโ€™s going on here. Yes, theyโ€™ve closed the loophole for some of the ETF freeriders by introducing custody charges to the GIA, and thatโ€™s fine. Yes, if you only trade once a year on your ยฃ250k SIPP into a multi-asset fund youโ€™ll save ยฃ247 a year and thatโ€™s good. And if youโ€™re a price-hound with straightforward investment needs you can get the in-house multi-asset thing plus your product charge for 0.45% all in, and thatโ€™s not terrible. If youโ€™re a cash-hound you have the active cash savings thingy, and if youโ€™re a workplace client with regulars going in you wonโ€™t pay fund trading charges anyway.  

So what gives in that core segment? I wonder if HL isnโ€™t spotting investor behaviour patterns change. Maybe thereโ€™s more trading on ETFs and investment trusts. Maybe trading volumes overall are rising; maybe HL sees outflows to competitors who donโ€™t charge a ruinous ยฃ11.95 a pop. Maybe dropping those trading charges for ETIs and introducing them for funds is the real story, and the 10bps cut isnโ€™t as big a deal. Itโ€™s many things, is HL, but none of them are stupid, and Iโ€™ve got a feeling this isnโ€™t just a straight-up act of bottom-line self-harm.  

The UK D2C market is a funny old place. Sticker price is a poor determinant of flow. There is a price-seeking segment of the market, and that segment is often rooted in active trading behaviour, which is where guys like ii and Freetrade go to work. There is another segment, at least as large, which is much less bothered, and just wants a name they know and to be confident their money will be there tomorrow. If HL has spotted that that segment is changing its behaviour, then we might be able to make a bit more sense โ€“ in the round, allowing for cash margins and all the rest of it โ€“ of whatโ€™s happening here. 

One further thing โ€“ there seems to be a belief that HL doing this will get others reviewing their pricing structures with a view to sharpening them. I think they will do that review and will make a change โ€“ upward. Someone had to go first with removing free fund trading. Watch for others breathing a sigh of relief and following suit. And if youโ€™re an adviser reading this โ€“ watch very carefully for contagion of fund trade charging crossing the floor into the advised platform market.  

Fun timesโ€ฆ

Your music choice this week is for aย real lifeย rain dog: my friend Steve, who got lost andย couldnโ€™tย find his way home.ย Iโ€™llย miss you, man. Thanks for introducing me to Tom Waits,ย and for many other things. Hereโ€™sย Singapore.ย ย 

/ Blogs

Impact of poor service

/ White papers

The Impact of Poor Service

We provided the research for a report, in conjunction with Parmenion, which reveals how far short of expectations many adviser platforms are falling. The research found that over the last 12 months, 88% of advisers needed to apologise to at least one of their clients on behalf of a platform, and that poor service delivery from platforms impacts 91% of advisers every day.

Impact of poor service

/ White papers

The Impact of Poor Platform Service

We provided the research for a report, in conjunction with Parmenion, which reveals how far short of expectations many adviser platforms are falling. The research found that over the last 12 months, 88% of advisers needed to apologise to at least one of their clients on behalf of a platform, and that poor service delivery from platforms impacts 91% of advisers every day.

/ White papers

Answering the Call

Service means a lot of things to a lot of different people. Itโ€™s so subjective it can be hard to put your finger on. This paper aims to challenge the status quo and inertia thatโ€™s built up in the sector for many years.